“Why did you approach me today?” I asked finally. “You could have just confronted them both and been done with it.”
Evan smiled, but it did not quite reach his eyes.
“Because I saw you sitting there looking so perfectly composed, and I recognized something in you. That careful contentment that people wear when they’re afraid to want more. I wore it for years in my marriage. And I thought maybe if you knew what I knew, you’d realize you deserve better than what you’re settling for.”
“You don’t even know me.”
“No,” he agreed. “But I’d like to, if you’ll let me.”
It was a line, probably. A move in whatever game he was playing. But sitting across from him in that beautiful restaurant, wearing the dress I had been told was too much, I realized I did not care. For one night, I wanted to be someone who said yes to possibility instead of no to risk.
“Okay,” I said. “Show me what happens next.”
The night unfolded like a dream I did not want to wake from. After dinner, Evan took me to a jazz club he knew, the kind of place where the music wrapped around you like velvet and no one asked questions about why two strangers were sitting so close together in a dark corner booth. We talked for hours, the words flowing easier than they had with anyone in longer than I could remember.
He told me about his marriage, how he and Diana had met young and ambitious, building a life together that looked perfect from the outside. They had bought a house in the suburbs, accumulated friends who were really just other couples going through the motions, and somewhere along the way had forgotten why they had chosen each other in the first place.
“We stopped being partners and started being roommates,” he said, swirling the whiskey in his glass. “I’d come home from work and she’d be watching television, and we’d exchange maybe ten words before going to sleep in the same bed like strangers. I kept thinking that’s just what marriage becomes after enough years. That passion was something you traded for stability.”
“When did you realize you were wrong?” I asked.“When I found the first email.” His jaw tightened. “She had written to Joel about how alive he made her feel, how she hadn’t known she could still want someone that way. And I realized she had never written anything like that about me. Not even at the beginning. I was always the safe choice, not the exciting one.”
I reached across the table and touched his hand, an impulse that surprised us both.
“That’s not true,” I said. “She just stopped choosing you, and that says more about her than it does about you.”
He looked at my hand on his, then up at my face, and something shifted in his expression. The carefully constructed confidence cracked for just a moment, revealing the wounded man beneath.
“You know what the worst part is?” he said quietly. “I’m not even sure I’m angry anymore. I’m just tired. Tired of pretending. Tired of hoping things will change. Tired of being someone’s backup plan while they chase someone else.”
“I understand that more than you know.”
“Do you still love him? Joel?”
The question caught me off guard and I had to sit with it for a moment, really examining my feelings for the first time.
“I thought I did,” I admitted. “For years, I would have said yes without hesitating. But looking back now, I think I loved the idea of him more than the reality. The idea of having a partner, of being chosen, of not being alone. The actual man never quite lived up to what I needed him to be.”
“That’s heartbreaking,” Evan said.
“Maybe. Or maybe it’s freeing. Because if I never really loved him, then losing him isn’t actually losing much at all.”
The jazz band shifted into something slower, more melancholic, and for a while we just sat there, two people processing grief that felt oddly shared. I had walked into this night expecting closure, expecting answers, expecting the kind of confrontation that would give me permission to move on. Instead, I had found something more complicated—a connection that felt dangerous precisely because it felt so real.
“Diana doesn’t know that I know,” Evan said eventually. “I’ve been waiting for the right moment to confront her. But the truth is, I’m not sure what I want that moment to look like. Anger, sadness. I can’t seem to find the right emotion for the occasion.”
“Maybe there isn’t one,” I said. “Maybe betrayal is just too complicated for a single feeling.”
He nodded slowly.
“When are you going to tell Joel?” he asked.
“I don’t know. Part of me wants to walk back into that apartment tonight and lay out every piece of evidence, watch him scramble for excuses. But another part of me thinks that would give him too much satisfaction. He’d get to be the victim then, the one who was attacked and accused, and somehow he’d twist it to make me the bad guy.”
“What if you didn’t give him that chance?”
“What do you mean?”
Evan leaned forward, his eyes intense.
“What if you just left? No confrontation, no explanation, no opportunity for him to manipulate the narrative. You pack your things while he’s at work. You disappear from his life the same way he disappeared from yours emotionally. And you let him wonder forever what he did wrong.”
The idea was appealing in its simplicity. No dramatic scene. No tears. No begging for answers that would never satisfy. Just a clean break, a closed door, a final refusal to participate in his deception.
“Could you do that?” I asked. “With Diana?”
“I’ve been thinking about it,” he admitted. “Walking away without giving her the satisfaction of seeing how much she hurt me.” He paused. “But I’m not sure I’m strong enough yet.”
“Maybe that’s why we found each other,” I said. “So we didn’t have to be strong alone.”
The words hung between us, charged with possibility. This was moving fast, too fast, and I knew I should pump the brakes, should put some distance between myself and this man who was technically still married to someone else. But the warmth of his hand under mine, the understanding in his eyes, the simple fact that he had seen my pain and chosen to share his own rather than exploit it, made slowing down feel impossible.
“What happens tomorrow?” I asked.
“Tomorrow we face reality,” he said. “But tonight we deserve this, whatever this is.”
I did not go home that night. Evan drove me to a hotel instead, insisting on getting me my own room despite the obvious tension that had been building between us. He walked me to my door, and for a long moment we just stood there, the hallway quiet and the air thick with everything unsaid.
For Complete Cooking STEPS Please Head On Over To Next Page Or Open button (>) and don’t forget to SHARE with your Facebook friends.
